

General Information Narrative Discourse Unit Goals Lesson I: Introduction Lesson II: The Outrageous Dreamers, Part I (1836-1899) Lesson III: The Outrageous Dreamers, Part II (1900-1980 Lesson IV: The Next Generation of Dreamers, The Urban Dream, 1981-Present Lesson V: A Call For Dreamers, Creating A Dream For Our Own Community
This curriculum unit is designed to be used in an English, Leadership, Vocational Construction, or Social Studies class, grades 10-12. It may also be used as a co-curricular unit. The entire unit may be completed in a minimum of six weeks. If students are allowed to work on projects in class, it may take longer. The unit requires three field trips. If these are not possible, speakers may be used to provide the information that may be obtained on these trips.
In a December 27, 1998 article titled “Houston Needs Dreamers,” Douglas Milburn stated how Houston from the very beginning has been blessed by dreamers--people of vision whose dreams in many cases seemed “beyond the limits of rational possibilities.” (Milburn 1) His partial list of dreamers included: Sam Houston, William Marsh Rice, the 1900 business community, Miss Ima Hogg, Jesse Jones, M. D. Anderson, John and Dominique de Menil, Judge Roy Hohfeinz, and Gerald Hines. He points out that there are still people in the city doing “new and creative things,” however, these things are small, fragmented--not the typical grand scale projects that were typical of the pre-1980s oil bust visionaries. He urges the reader, therefore, to focus on the potential for reviving downtown city life. Here, he believes, lies the inspiration which could prompt the great dreamers to produce the grandiose vision of such luminaries as Sam Houston or Ima Hogg. But alas, there seem to be no such dreamers to be found in this fair city and this leaves Milburn pondering the plaintive query, “Where is the next generation of Houston’s outrageous dreamers?”
“Where is the next generation of Houston’s outrageous dreamers?” “All around us” seems to be Henry A. de la Garza’s response in his article, “ City Talk/Houston Still Has Plenty of Dreamers.” Noting Houston’s new dreamers are still being inspired by the dreams of their predecessors and would hardly desire to be called outrageous, de la Garza presents his own “very, very” partial list of dreamers who have enriched our community. These include: Truett Latimer, Rod Canion, Reverend Kirbyjon Caldwell, Michael Feinberg, City Councilmember Martha Wong, and Nicholas Kanellos. In his closing paragraphs, he describes how, in 1986, after some 250,000 Houston Houstonians had lost their jobs within two years, Houstonians of vision began building the $70 million dollar Gus Wortham Theatre. Every single dollar came from private funds (a visionary accomplishment to be compared with Milburn’s mention of the dream of the 1900 business community to build a port 50 miles inland). So he concludes that perhaps the image of the Houston dreamer is found in the words of the 19th century poet, Arthur O’Shaughnessy: “...We are the music makers...we are the dreamers...we are the movers and shakers.”
Today, Houston, like many other cities across the nation, has recognized that it cannot survive if its urban areas are run-down and neglected. Its citizens of vision (dreamers), like others all across the nation, are joining together to help breathe new life into old, decaying, outmoded areas and infrastructures. The need to create cities for all of the people requires that visions and decision-making must be shared. The size and sheer expense of revitalization is so huge, that it necessitates an incremental approach. The diversity of needs and communities to be served mandate that some energy and resources are directed toward smaller, less global “dreams.”
Though considerably smaller than Houston, Chattanooga, Tennessee (pop. 148,820) was once a “prime example for everything wrong with post-industrial America.” (Graham 4) In the 1970s, it was dying from smog (“air so dirty you had to drive with your headlights on at noon”), a decrepit downtown district, decaying river front, and poor mass transit. Today, as reported in the article, “Our Restored Cities, Where The Living Is Easier,” it has, through a combination of community involvement with public, nonprofit and commercial investment, solved many of its problems. In fact, the city has received two UN awards and a 1996 award from the President’s Council on Sustainable Development.
Successful revitalization efforts seem to involve a combination of community involvement with public, nonprofit and commercial investment. In the past, (re)gentrification was considered to the key element of such change. However, today, other factors-- such as, the need to attract international business and tourists; shifting migrant populations in some areas; and an emerging younger workforce--seem to sound a death knell for (re)gentrification. Instead, today’s vision must be global; its cultural symbols and the dreamers/visionaries--age and culturally diverse.
Veterans of Chattanooga’s revitalization campaign give the following advice on how to start turning a community around:
3. Listen to experts who understand revitalization.
4. Start small. Start with something that can be easily done and builds a feeling of success.(Graham 5)
Clearly, if present revitalization efforts in Houston are to create a framework for a process that will give birth to the type of dynamic change needed to keep the city alive, they will not be fostered by a few “grandiose” dreamers whose vision changes the face of the community as a whole. Instead, for the most part, they will emanate from and be maintained by less formidable dreamers who collaborate with other others to produce incremental change. Many hundreds of millions of dollars and other resources are being allocated to renew the face of this city. The leadership for this effort emanates from a group of middle aged and older dreamers who, alone do not possess the longevity or resources needed to insure that such change is perpetuated. Revitalization is a dream that should be understood and espoused by all of the people as we build cities that will serve the needs of diverse populations. Therefore, if such efforts are to survive, the voices and visions of youth must be heard. Urban revitalization is an ongoing process, requiring initiation, preservation and perpetuation of a collective vision. Perhaps, if young people are included in the mechanism of change, the “life” of the city will be afforded a better chance of survival.
1. To acquaint students with the early history of the city of Houston.
Lesson I
Upon completion of this unit, students should be able to:
One (1) 90 minute class period.
Class set of: “Houston Needs Dreamers” by Douglas Milburn and “City Talk/Houston Still Has Plenty of Dreamers” by Henry A. de la Garza Markers Chart Pad Adhesive Tape
Assessment:
Formal assessment of Handout 1-A and class participation in discussion.
Part I. The Outrageous Dreamers
(Use the article “Houston Needs Dreamers” by Douglas Milburn to complete the following activities.)
1. Use context clues to define the following terms:
A. visionaries G. modest M. meandering
B. rational H. vitality
C. leavening I. infrastructure
D. traumatized J. renovating
E. aesthetics K. urban
F. civic L. post-bust period
(Use the article, “City Talk/Houston Still Has Plenty of Dreamers” by Henry A. de la Garza to complete the following activities.)
1. Vocabulary: Use context clues to define the following terms.
A. heritage G. empowerM. nurturing
B. enrich H. at-risk kidsN. cadre
C. artifacts I. charter school O. random
D. envisioned J. daunting P. status quo
E. transform K. fledglingQ. solicited
F. ravaging L. memorabilia R. calamity
Directions: Near the end of this unit, you will be asked to write an essay that responds to the views expressed by Douglas Milburn, in the article, “Houston Needs Dreamers.” In your essay, you will be asked to either agree or disagree with his position and support your ideas with information about current community leaders, projects and/or initiatives.
On this page, list at least five (5) things that you feel you will need to know in order to respond to this issue. Also, include any questions that you feel need to be answered about Houston and its leaders, and/or their accomplishments.
Lesson II
Upon completion of this unit, students should be able to -
1. Identify important sites or persons such as:
Time Needed: Two (2) to three (3) ninety minute class periods
Posters and Markers (for timelines)Handouts (Outline for Visit to Historical Homes)Computers with internet connections
Achievement will be assessed through formal grading of completed handouts, student reports, completion of timelines/posters, an essay, and participation in class discussion.
TIMELINES
Directions: Form three groups of 3-5 students. Each group will select one of the
following time frames: Group A 1836-1849 Group B 1850-1875 Group C 1876-1899
Each group member will write a short report (1/2 to one full page) about two significant events that occurred during the assigned period. Be sure to include information about the size of Houston (area) and its population at the time of each event. Extra credit will be given if you can provide pictures that relate to your events(s).
Once you have completed your individual reports, as a group, you will create a time line on a trifold poster board. Attach your report and pictures to the relevant dates on your timeline. Title your poster: Highlights in Houston History
(18____ to 18_____) Due Date: Your group will make an oral presentation of this project on __________ (date). Each group member is responsible for sharing his or her own work.
Resources: Ray Miller’s Houston by Ray Miller History: A History by David G. McComb Houston Public Library (Texas and Local History Department in the Julia Ideson Building, across from the downtown public library) University of Houston Library
Houston History,
http://www.texasbest.com/houston/history.html, (10 June 99) The Handbook of Texas Online, http://www.tsha.utexas.edu/handbook/online/search.html, (June 10, 1999).
Assessment: Written Report 40 points (Individual Grade) Poster 40 points (Group Grade) Oral Report 20 points (Individual Grade) Pictures 3 points (Individual Grade)
(Be sure to given proper credit to any cited work. Failure to do so will result in a grade of “0”.)
Directions: Form three groups of 3-5 students. Each group will research the lives and contributions of certain “outrageous dreamers” who had a significant impact on the further of Houston during 1836-99. Each student will write a short report (minimum of one full page) on the life and contribution of each individual. The report will also discuss why the individual’s contribution(s) were important and how they affected the future growth and development of the city. Related pictures are required. Reports must include, but not be necessarily limited to the following individuals:
| Group A | Group B | Group C |
|---|---|---|
| Jacob Binz | The Borden Brothers | Thomas Baggy |
| The Allen Brothers | William Marsh Rice | Charles Love |
| Charlotte Allen | George Henry Herman | Richard Allen |
| Sam Houston | Reverend Jack Yates | Thomas Scanlan |
| Colonel Hugh Rice | Charles Morgan | George T. Ruby |
| Ernest O. Smith | James Stevens | Lorenz de Several |
Once you have completed your individual reports, then as a group, you will create a booklet. Title your booklet (like this lesson): The Outrageous Dreamers, 1835-1899. Place your information in a binder. Reports must be typed. Footnotes and appropriate citations must be given.
Due Date: Your group will make an oral presentation of this project on ___________ (date). Each group member is responsible for presenting his/her own part of the project.
Resources:The Handbook of Texas Online, http://www.tsha.utexas.edu/handbook/online/search.html (10 June 99)
Assessment: Written Report50 points (Individual Grade)
Oral Report20 points (Individual Grade)
Booklet25 points (Group Grade)
Pictures 5 points each (Individual Grade)
(Proper credit must be given to all cited sources. Failure to do so will result in a grade of “0”.)
Directions: Form two groups of 2-5 students who will read pages 1-47 of Ray Miller’s Houston. Based on your reading, you will collect information about certain historical sites in Houston. The original structures at many of these sites may no longer exist. However, the sites still possess their special historical significance. You will collect and format certain data on each of the sites mentioned in the Miller reading (or any other sites you feel are relevant and significant.) The data should include:
A. Original Structure/Event
B. Date Constructed/Event Occurred
C. Historical significance of Location (including other structures built after the original structure or event.)
D. Present Site: Existing Structure(s)
Location (Street Address) In addition to the sites listed in the Miller reading, include information on the following: The Gregory Institute; Riceville, Texas; Freedman’s Town; Antioch Church; the Port of Houston; Emancipation Park.
As a group, create a mini-tour guide to important historical sites related to Houston’s history during 1836-1899. Create a suitable format for presenting the information and type all information included in the guide. Related pictures are required. Title your guide: A Guide to Historical sites in Houston (1836-1899).
Due Date: Your group will make an oral presentation of this project on _____________(date). Each group member is responsible for presenting his/her work.
Resources: Ray Miller’s Houston by Ray Miller The Houston Heritage Society Houston Public Library (Texas and Local History Department in the Julia Ideson Building, across from the downtown public library) Freedman’s Town Association
| Assessment: Written Report | 25 points (Individual) |
| Booklet | |
| Content | 20 points (Group) |
| Presentation | 30 points (Group) |
| Creativity | 20 points (Group) |
| Pictures | 2 points (Group) |
Lesson III
Upon completion of the unit, students should be able to-
Minimum Time Needed: Two to three 90- minute class periods for project completion, reporting, and discussion. One additional period is needed for the speaker and one day for the field trip.
Materials and Supplies:Posters and Markers (for Timelines) Handouts 3-A/B/C Computers with internet connections
(10) most important visionaries in Houston during 1900 through 1980.
Formal assessment will be provided through completion of projects, handouts, class participation.
Teacher Note: Using Handout 2-A as a model, this information must be used to create Handout 3-A. It is strongly recommended that all group assignments for this unit are assigned at the beginning of the unit, in order to expedite time and avoid lapses in instructional time. Some regrouping may be necessary since only three (3) groups were used in Handout 2-A.
Students will be divided into the following groups. There should be no more than 3-5
students in each group. Group A 1900-1920 Group B 1921-1940 Group C 1941-1960 Group D 1961-1980
Title: Houston History (1900-1920)
Teacher Note: These revisions are needed to create Handout 3-B. Some regrouping will be necessary since only three (3) groups were required to complete this assignment in
| Handout 2-B. | ||
|---|---|---|
| Group A | Group B | Group C |
| Ima Hogg | Carter G. Wesley | E. W. Scripps |
| Jesse H. Jones | Monroe D. Anderson | George Hermann |
| Reverend Jack Yates | Dr. Lonnie Smith | Frank and Ross Sterling |
| Hugh Roy Cullen | Mrs. Anna Bell Robinson | Howard Hughes |
| William Marsh Rice | Joseph F. Cullinan | George R. Brown |
| Roy Hofheinz | Glen McCarthy | James D. Ryan |
| Oscar Holcombe | Leonel Castillo | Louis Welch |
| Ninfa Laurenzo | Rev. Bill Lawson | Bud Adams |
| Group D | ||
| Gerald Hines | Heman Sweatt | |
| Moses Leroy | Kenneth Schnitzer | |
| Christia Adair | Dr. Lonnie Smith | |
| Barbara Jordan | Albert Thomas | |
Teacher Note: Only two groups are needed for this assignment.
Group A will cover 1900-1946 Group B will cover 1947-1980 Title of Tour Guide: A Guide to Historical Sites (1900-1980)
The Next Generation of Dreamers (The Urban Dream, 1981 - Present)
Upon completion of this unit, student will be able to:
1. Identify the vision and contributions of individuals and groups such as:
Rev. Kirbyjohn Caldwell Former Mayor Bob Lanier Nicholas Kanellos Councilwoman Martha Wong Mayor Lee Brown Rod Canion The Renaissance Group City Planning Department The OST Redevelopment Corporation Cultural Arts Council of Houston Houston Sports Authority METRO Greater Houston Partnership Housing and Urban Development
2 Define: revitalization, regentrification.
6. Identify the influence that culture has on revitalization.
Time Required: 2 weeks
Posters and Markers (For Timeline)Glue, Scissors, and RulersHandouts 4 A-D
Strategies:
Formal assessment will be provided through review of completed handouts, notes, the assigned essay, projects, and class discussion.
Teacher Note: Use the following information to create Handout 4-A by revising Handout 2-A. Only one group of three to five students will be needed to complete this activity.
Group A will cover 1980-Present Title: Houston History (1980 - Present)
Kathy Whitmire Bob Lanier The Greater Houston Partnership Lee Brown Rev. Kirbyjohn Caldwell Cultural Arts Council of Houston Councilperson Martha Wong Felix Fraga Rod Canion Houston Sports Authority Metro Frank Lorenzo Kenneth Lay Nicholas Kannellos Congresswoman Sheila Jackson Lee Third Ward Redevelopment Corporation Renaissance Group LULAC NAACP Port of Houston Authority
Title: The Next Generation of Dreamers 1980-Present
Teacher Note: Use this information to create Handout 4-C by revising Handout 2-C. You will need two groups of 3-5 students to complete this task.
Group A will identify the location of at least important historical sites. Group B will identify the location of at least ten current revitalization project sites.
Title: A Guide to Houston (1980-Present)
Additional Resource: The Houston Chronicle Online Archives (only available to subscribers) http://www.chron.com, 10 June 99.
(To be used with the reading, “Our Restored Cities, Where the Living is Easier” by Lamar Graham.)
Instructional Objectives:
Upon completion of this unit, students should be able to:
Time Required: Two (2) Weeks
PostersDrawing PaperMap Pencils, Pencils, Chalk, Colors, Markers, Erasers, etc.HandoutsCamera
Formal assessment will include review of student projects, field trip notes, and written discussion paper.
Graham, Lamar. “Our Restored Cities, Where the Living Is Easier.” Parade Magazine April 25, 1999, 4-6.
Article which defines urban revitalization and discusses revitalization efforts in several cities, including Chattanooga, Tennessee.
McComb, David G. Houston: A History. Austin: University of Texas Press, 1981.
Excellent, classic urban biography of Houston which chronicles the efforts of successful Houston businessmen and events that have helped to shape the politics, economics, and culture of the city. Is interesting and full of local color.
Miller, Ray. Ray Miller’s Houston. (Second Edition). Houston: Gulf Publishing Company, 1992.
Students will enjoy the conversational tone of this book. It covers the history of Houston from 1836 to around 1987. It is replete with interesting photographs and well and lesser known facts about Houston. It is an excellent resource for the timeline and guided tour groups. This book is out of print. However, it can be found in public and university libraries. Persons looking for a personal copy may contact the following out-of-print locator: Mr. William Dobbs of Lodowick Adams Bookseller, 1-800-476-2155 or by email at L.adamsbk@cwixmail.com.
Electronic Sources
de la Garza, Henry, “City Talk/Houston Still Has Plenty of Dreamers”, Houston
Chronicle, 3 Jan., 1999 in Outlook Section, The Houston Chronicle Archives,
http://www.chron.com, (10 June, 1999).
Newpaper article which proposes that there are plenty of dreamers around even if they are not the stature of what Doug Milburn calls “outrageous” dreamers. The achives may be accessed online by persons with a Chronicle subscription number.
Houston History, http://www.texasbest.com/houston/history.html, (10 June, 1999).
A timeline of Houston history from 1836 to present.
Milburn, Douglas, “Houston Needs Dreamers”, Houston Chronicle, 27 Dec. 1998 in Outlook Section, The Houston Chronicle Archives, http://www.chron.com, (10 June, 1999).
Author believes that there have been no more outrageous dreamers/visionaries in Houston, Texas since in 1980’s oil bust.
The Handbook of Texas Online, http://www.tsha.utexas.edu/handbook/online/search. html (10 June, 1999).
A three volume “multidisciplinary encyclopedia of Texas history, geography, and culture.” It contains over 23,000 articles on just about anything you’d want to know about Texas. A rare find.
The Houston Chronicle Archives, http://www.chron.com, (10 June, 1999).
This service is available to Houston Chronicle subscribers only. However, every school has some type of subscription with this newspaper. It is an excellent resource.